The brouhaha developing from Mel Gibson's arrest over the weekend is kind of puzzling to me. It's not even the belligerence he exhibited, the utter lack of respect for law and order--it's the anti-Semitic remarks he's alleged to have made.
I am not defending Mel Gibson. What he said, he said. If it was anti-Semitic, then he's among the world's richest bigots. Not exactly something to boast about...but that's his business. My focus today is on another aspect of his history that has come up yet again, as a result of the arrest.
When 'Passion of the Christ' came out, there was a veritable firestorm of criticism for it. To quote from a recent Reuters article, "Many Jews and others were upset that "The Passion of the Christ" revived ancient Christian accusations that Jews bore responsibility for Jesus' death."
Yeah, well, guess what? They were. It's history. It happened over 2000 years ago. Move on with life, people. I don't bear a grudge against the state of Tennessee because my great-grandfather was chased out of the state by the KKK. I don't even bear a grudge against the KKK for the incident (why bother? There are so many other, current, legitimate reasons to despise them...)
The Germans were responsible for the Holocaust, but you don't see people howling in outrage about Germany (well, not about that aspect of Germany, at least.) Russia was guilty of the pogroms, and sent thousands of people to die in work camps. Japan attacked Pearl Harbor, Spain had its Inquisition, just about everyone in the world has had slavery at one point or another (some probably still do, I don't keep up on that), Europe and the Catholic Church were responsible for the chaos and mayhem of the Crusades, Scandinavia released the scourge that was the Viking raids, Eastern Europe and Western Asia had the Goths and Huns who destroyed Rome, who had the atrocities of the gladiatorial arenas...these are all historical facts. We have accepted them, and moved on. Italy didn't cry foul when Gladiator painted their ancestors as a somewhat barbaric and murderous lot. Russia doesn't whine about the fact that millions of people continue to read "A Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich".
Forgive and forget. Well, okay...don't forget, because if we do that we never learn the lessons of history. But how many of the world's conflicts would never have started if people weren't still fighting the wars their ancestors started? It's history, and we can't change it. We can whitewash it, we can conveniently not talk about it...but we can't change it. No amount of bloodshed will change it. Neither will walking around, expecting the world to apologize for centuries of bigotry inspired by one event. It's already happened, no one can take it back.
So accept it, and stop trying to make up for the past. Stop expecting people to atone for the sins of ancestors who've long been dead. We've got enough problems to deal with on our own, without carrying forward problems from ages gone by.